Carney’s China deal signals a strategic pivot for Canada
Mark Carney struck a tariff-for-trade agreement with China that opens markets for canola and seafood and allows thousands of Chinese EVs into Canada, signalling a clear shift from reliance on the U.S.
Copy link
By Torontoer Staff
Prime Minister Mark Carney returned from a two-day visit to Beijing with what he described as a "preliminary but landmark" deal that reduces Chinese tariffs on Canadian canola, lobster, crab and peas, in exchange for allowing imports of Chinese-made electric vehicles. He framed the agreement as part of a broader, pragmatic reorientation of Canadian foreign and trade policy away from exclusive dependence on the United States.
Carney said the tariff changes will take effect in March and run at least through the end of the year. He also gave a target to expand trade: double non-U.S. exports within a decade and increase exports to China by 50 per cent over four years.
The deal, in brief
Officials described the agreement as an initial, practical step to reopen markets on both sides. Details remain partly preliminary, and Chinese government statements emphasised broader cooperation rather than listing exact tariff cuts.
- 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles slated for import, according to Carney
- Canola meal, lobsters, crabs and peas to be exempt from Chinese tariffs from March through at least year-end
- A wider push to deepen trade, investment and technical exchanges, including EV expertise
Carney’s rationale: pragmatic engagement
Carney said Canada will pursue "pragmatic and constructive engagement" with other countries on a case-by-case basis, forming coalitions where interests align. He framed the shift as realism about a changing global order and stressed that engagement does not mean abandoning values.
There is "more than one disruptive superpower in the world,"
Prime Minister Mark Carney
He called China, an authoritarian regime, a significant player on climate and multilateral issues, and said candid, consistent dialogue with Beijing has produced more predictable results recently. Carney reaffirmed Canada's support for the One China policy on Taiwan and said Canada continues to stand up for human rights and democracy.
We take the world as it is, not as we wish it to be.
Prime Minister Mark Carney
Domestic and international pushback
The deal drew immediate criticism from domestic political opponents and cautious reaction from the United States. Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre warned the plan jeopardises jobs and security, saying the government had reversed earlier warnings about China as a security threat. Ontario Premier Doug Ford called the agreement a "mess."
President Donald Trump gave a brief nod to the outcome, but a U.S. trade official offered a sterner view. "I think it’s problematic for Canada," U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer told CNBC, adding, "I think in the long run, they’re not going to like having made that deal."
Risks and unanswered questions
The Chinese foreign ministry issued general statements about lengthening cooperation and shortening irritants, but did not disclose specific tariff schedules. Canadian officials said they have "full confidence" in China’s commitments. Observers note gaps remain on issues such as security implications, supply-chain resilience and whether human rights concerns will affect longer-term ties.
Carney did not specify whether discussions with President Xi included China’s relationship with Russia or other geopolitical flashpoints. He said Canada expects NATO partners to meet their obligations, and urged respect for the sovereignty of Greenland and Denmark amid threats of U.S. tariff pressure.
What comes next
Carney leaves Beijing for Doha in search of investment and broader Middle East ties, then plans to attend the World Economic Forum in Davos. Implementation of tariff changes and follow-up talks with Chinese and allied partners will be the immediate focus. The government will need to answer how imports of Chinese EVs will affect domestic auto jobs and industrial policy, and how commitments will be monitored.
Carney framed the shift as deliberate and forward-looking. "Nostalgia is not a strategy," he told reporters in Beijing.
Bottom line
The China agreement is a clear departure from an exclusively U.S.-centred trade posture. It aims to reopen Canadian agricultural and seafood markets and speed an EV transition, while testing how Canada balances trade diversification, national security and human rights. The coming months will show whether the early, pragmatic steps translate into durable results.
Mark CarneyChinatradeelectric vehiclescanolaCanada
